PDA

View Full Version : General Comment from a Maya Lover



lilnyc
09-19-2010, 09:00 AM
I have resisted Cinema 4D with great passion for a while. I am trained in and prefer Maya, but my career has shifted me into motion graphics with After Effects. I was determined to just use Maya for motion graphics despite the less fluid workflow between the two. However, I now have a job where they resist Maya, and use Cinema 4D. in fact, only ONE person is a master of it, so he's guaranteed work.

I have an upcoming project where I have to represent sound, visually. The first thing that came to mind was Red Giant's Trapcode Sound Keys...until I spotted the Digital Tutors Cinema 4D tutorial on the visual sound project. Just looking at the preview, and knowing of my limited Cinemd 4D knowledge, I thought I couldn't do that in one sitting, but in just the 1st lesson, I was following along and making something cool with ease. I didn't want to stop.

This encouraged me to look into Cinema 4D R12's new features for motion graphics. I am beyond impressed, and finally understand why it's so useful with After Effects.

I know that I will now need to revert to the basics and really learn the essentials, but I no longer feel that it's a waste of time. I really feel that it's a viable, necessary tool as much as Photoshop is for a multimedia artist. It is essential. So I will continue with Maya for the love of it, but Cinema 4D is also a must, and I am thrilled that Digital Tutors has started tutorials on it. There's no better place to learn in my opinion.

jclark
10-22-2010, 06:32 PM
Most any package is capable, but you won't find one so optimized as C4D for motion graphics. The Mograph module is such a worthwhile component not only for motion graphics, but it adds a lot to the modleing workflow. The integration to AE is just downright simple and the support for the mult-pass is a breeze.

Granted the mpass system isn't as elaborate as Maya but it's usable for efficient results.

Glad to hear your comments, and the fact you were able to try it honestly and appreciate is noble. Too many sluff off C4D, just because it doesn't have the infiltration of Maya or that it's stereotyped as just a motion graphics / broadcast tool.

Enjoy.

CarstenSB
10-23-2010, 11:27 AM
I am not a cinema fanboy but check out this portfolio http://www.mostyle.tv/. Especially the mtv opener are cool. I saw this guy showing some live tutorials . It was amazing what cinemas mograph/ modynamics are capable of.